Brass: Birmingham vs Scythe

Side by side comparison of two top board games

Brass: Birmingham

Brass: Birmingham

⭐ 8.6# 3💰 $65👤 2-4

Brass: Birmingham is an economic strategy game sequel to Martin Wallace's Brass. It tells the story of competing entrepreneurs in Birmingham during the industrial revolution. Players must build networks of canals and railways, develop industries, and trade goods. The game features a unique economic system where players can use each other's networks and resources.

EconomicIndustry / ManufacturingTransportation
Scythe

Scythe

⭐ 8.3# 7💰 $75👤 1-5

Scythe is an engine-building game set in an alternate-history 1920s Europe. Players control factions seeking power and influence through economic development, area control, and combat. Each player builds their economic engine by constructing buildings, farming resources, and deploying mechs. The game features a unique combat system and beautiful artwork.

EconomicFarmingScience FictionTerritory Building

Specification Comparison

SpecBrass: BirminghamScythe
BGG Rank3 ✓7
Rating8.6 ✓8.3
Year Published20182016 ✓
Price65 ✓75
Min Players21 ✓
Max Players45 ✓
Play Time (min)120115 ✓
Min Age1414
Complexity (1-5)3.85 ✓3.44

Brass: Birmingham wins in 4 categories, Scythe wins in 4 categories.

Brass: Birmingham — Time Estimates

2-Player Game60 min
Quick session with a smaller group
4-Player Game120 min
Full table experience
Learning Session120 min
First time playing (includes setup & rule explanation)

Scythe — Time Estimates

1-Player Game90 min
Quick session with a smaller group
5-Player Game115 min
Full table experience
Learning Session133 min
First time playing (includes setup & rule explanation)

Category & Mechanic Comparison

Brass: Birmingham

Categories
EconomicIndustry / ManufacturingTransportation
Mechanics
Hand ManagementHexagon GridIncomeLoanMarketNetwork and Route BuildingTile PlacementVariable Phase Order

Scythe

Categories
EconomicFarmingScience FictionTerritory Building
Mechanics
Action PointsArea Majority / InfluenceAsymmetric Starting PositionsCard DraftingEngine BuildingHand ManagementHexagon GridModular BoardVariable Player Powers

Rating Comparison

Brass: Birmingham8.6
Scythe8.3

Frequently Asked Questions

Which game has a higher rating, Brass: Birmingham or Scythe?
Brass: Birmingham has a rating of 8.6, while Scythe has 8.3. Brass: Birmingham is rated higher.
Which game is more affordable, Brass: Birmingham or Scythe?
Brass: Birmingham costs approximately $65 and Scythe costs approximately $75. Brass: Birmingham is the more affordable option.
Which game supports more players, Brass: Birmingham or Scythe?
Brass: Birmingham supports 2-4 players and Scythe supports 1-5 players. Scythe supports more players.
Is Brass: Birmingham or Scythe more complex?
On a scale of 1-5, Brass: Birmingham has a complexity weight of 3.85 and Scythe has 3.44. Brass: Birmingham is the more complex game.
Which game has a shorter play time, Brass: Birmingham or Scythe?
Brass: Birmingham takes about 120 minutes to play, while Scythe takes about 115 minutes. Scythe is the quicker game.

Related Comparisons

Brass: Birmingham vs GloomhavenScythe vs Gloomhaven
Brass: Birmingham vs Pandemic Legacy: Season 1Scythe vs Pandemic Legacy: Season 1
Brass: Birmingham vs Terraforming MarsScythe vs Terraforming Mars
Brass: Birmingham vs Through the Ages: A New Story of CivilizationScythe vs Through the Ages: A New Story of Civilization
Brass: Birmingham vs Star Wars: RebellionScythe vs Star Wars: Rebellion
Brass: Birmingham vs Puerto RicoScythe vs Puerto Rico